Has it ever occured to you after you read a book how much research its author put into it? Suzanne Collins not only thoroughly understands the topic of a dystopian world, but also several psychological disorders born from the issues that such a home would cause. I wasn't aware of just how much time that she put into this series however, until after I read 'Bent, Shattered, and Mended.'
Things we take for granted now wouldn't apply in a world like the arena, or even the regular life of District 12. There's hardly ever happiness, and even then, there is always the knowledge that the Capitol can take that away whenver it wants to. Maybe that is why that I didn't really connect to Katniss as a character at first, until I realized that she would do anything for her extended family.
I wonder if we would be just the same as Katniss, Peeta, Gale, and others are if we were forced to be part of a dictatorship. Would we feel that giving someone your trust is handing them a gun that's pointed directly at you? Would we think that owing someone is an edge that they have over you? Little things like a handshake could have dozens of hidden strings, and it's too risky to ignore any small detail. As 'Bent, Shattered, and Mended' said, the brain goes into hyperdrive.
That must be the reason why Katniss communicates so well with Haymitch. He recognizes himself in her in the way that she looks at every small detail in the world and doubts that it's genuine. This is also why he knows that she will pick up on the strings attached to a bucket of soup.
So despite all of the pyschological torture that the Capitol puts the Districts through to control them (The Hunger Games), bonds can happen too, even in the arena. So is it all worth it? If it hadn't been for the miserable circumstances in the world of the President Snow's dictatorship, Katniss would have noticed Peeta only in passing, and never have spoken to Haymitch. Prim might not mean as much to Katniss, because she would no longer be the one constant in Katniss's life. Her father would still be alive, and she might be just like any other normal teenage girl. Once again, is it worth it? In the end of 'Mockingjay', Katniss marries Peeta, and all of her mental trauma finally heals enough to let her have a family with Peeta.
I think the Capitol never took into account that the Hunger Games was also a spark that started the rebellion, or more specifically, started Katniss. Even though the tributes loose their individuality as a person in the interviews ('...erase my face with a layer of pale makeup'), showing that they are only an ornament, they still understand each other in the sense that most of them would never willingly take another human life. In some degree, all of the tributes feel resentment for being thrown into the world of the arena.
That is something that the Capitol will never understand, having never faced poverty, hunger, or lack of anything.
WOW, you are an amazing writer, you have proven to be my mentor. You not only obviously put a lot of time into it when you consider the length but you also used amazing wording. After I read this it seemed impossible for me to believe that a middle school student wrote this. I really agree that there is a lot of research that must have went in to making this series. It must have been hard for her to write this from the perspective of a girl going hungry and then being forced to fight for her life in an arena for the capital's pleasure because I am pretty sure that didn't apply to her. Great job!
ReplyDeleteSometimes I hate you because you are such a good writer and you are so smart. :) (Just kidding, I love you.) I agree with almost everything you said. I love your ideas on Haymitch's and Katniss's connection. Your vocabulary is so advanced, it makes your ideas just that much more interesting. However, I would have to respectfully disagree with you about the Arena being, "worth it." You have to remember, the Games are designed so only one victor can win. These were special circumstances. The bonds tributes may build are meant to be broken, the same people you allied with are meant to kill you, and vice-versa. Look at what happened to Rue. Also, the game makers intended for Katniss to kill Peeta. Not for both of them to live. In my opinion, there's no way the essence of the Games have anything positive about them. In Katniss's case, sure, there were some positive notes, but that's only because she outsmarted the capitol.
ReplyDelete